steuber draft journal



Draft Nemesis: DeCastro vs. Glenn
Posted: February 20, 2012
Comments
| Top


Georgia's Cordy Glenn has the size and versatility that teams covet, but can he surpass Stanford's David DeCastro?
Georgia Athletics

In my previous Draft Nemesis features I've analyzed the top-two quarterbacks in the draft, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Baylor's Robert Griffin III (click here to view it), as well as two of the premier running backs, Oregon's LaMichael James and Lamar Miller (click here to view it), the top-two wide receivers, Oklahoma State's Justin Blackmon and Baylor's Kendall Wright (click here to view it), tight ends, Clemson's Dwayne Allen and Georgia's Orson Charles (click here to view it) and offensive tackles, Iowa's Riley Reiff and USC's Matt Kalil (click here to view it).

Today, I turn my attention towards the top-two offensive guards. Stanford's David DeCastro is the premiere interior offensive lineman in the draft, and is widely regarded as a possible Top 10 draft pick. Georgia's Cordy Glenn is coming on strong after a solid showing at the Senior Bowl, and the size and versatility that he possesses will be attractive to teams that hold Top 20 selections.

Again, the Draft Nemesis feature is a condensed breakdown featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board, Mock Draft and/or Top 100.

Click here to view the latest Draft Nemesis feature between DeCastro and Glenn.

 




Draft Nemesis: Allen vs. Charles
Posted: February 17, 2012
Comments
| Top


Clemson's Dwayne Allen is the No. 1 TE in my rankings, but Georgia's Orson Charles isn't far behind.
Clemson Athletics

In my previous Draft Nemesis features I've analyzed the top-two quarterbacks in the draft, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Baylor's Robert Griffin III (click here to view it), as well as two of the premier running backs, Oregon's LaMichael James and Lamar Miller (click here to view it), the top-two wide receivers, Oklahoma State's Justin Blackmon and Baylor's Kendall Wright (click here to view it) and offensive tackles, Iowa's Riley Reiff and USC's Matt Kalil (click here to view it).

Today, I turn my attention to the tight end position. In my opinion, there isn't a TE worthy of a first-round pick, but the top-two TEs, Clemson's Dwayne Allen and Georgia's Orson Charles, will challenge for opening frame consideration and I pose them against each other in my latest Draft Nemesis feature.

Again, the Draft Nemesis feature is a condensed breakdown featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board, Mock Draft and/or Top 100.

Click here to view the latest Draft Nemesis feature between Allen and Charles.

 




Oklahoma WR Ryan Broyles Bouncing Back
Posted: February 17, 2012
Comments
| Top


Oklahoma wide receiver Ryan Broyles is ahead of schedule in his recovery from ACL surgery and is looking to prove to scouts he's back.
Oklahoma Athletics

Three months removed from season-ending ACL surgery, Oklahoma wide receiver Ryan Broyles confirmed with me during a phone interview that he’s training in California and is back on the field; in his words, “doing everything, but not everything at full speed,” as he prepares for the NFL Scouting Combine, which takes place on February 22nd – 28th in Indianapolis.

The encouraging news on Broyles is that not only is he back on the field, but he ran a 40-yard dash a couple of days ago and was timed at a 4.70. That is a great sign and it shows how much progress he's made in just a few months. When asked what he ran the 40 in prior to the injury, Broyles said, “Prior to the injury, I ran a 4.4.”

The 5-foot-10, 190-pound Broyles confirmed that he’s attending the Scouting Combine next week and will take part in the bench press and team interviews. He also said that he hopes to get a Pro Day together sometime in April. He plans on running the 40 at that time to show NFL personnel that he’s ahead of schedule and is close to his original form.

"I’m going to go in there and show them my personality and let them know I’m a hard worker," Broyles said. "Nothing is going to hold me back; this injury is not going to hold me back. I’m a student of the game; I’m always trying to learn as much as I can and be as prepared as possible."

After a standout junior campaign where he caught 131 passes (2nd in the nation) for 1,622 yards (4th in the nation) and 14 touchdowns, Broyles decided to return to Oklahoma for his senior season. If he decided to declare for the 2011 NFL Draft, he would’ve likely been a Top 40 selection.

Looking back at what could’ve been, Broyles has no regrets about his decision to return to Norman, Oklahoma for his senior year and said, “God put me in this position for a reason. I didn’t feel like it was the right move for me to leave school early. I knew I had to prepare more as a player and I was able to do a lot of things outside of football: I went to Haiti, I proposed to my fiancée; I feel like I’ve grown more mentally over the past year.”

Prior to the injury he suffered against Texas A&M on November 5th, Broyles was well on his way to approaching the statistical output he posted in 2010, as he hauled in 83 receptions for 1,157 yards and 10 touchdowns in nine games. However, despite the consistency and production he displayed during his career, Broyles was recently told that he projects to be a 3rd – 5th draft pick, mainly due to his injury.

That projection didn’t sit well with Broyles, he said, “I’m a prideful guy and a competitor, and if I didn’t have this injury I would be up there with the best of them.” I agreed with Broyles on his assessment. If he finished his senior season healthy, he would be mentioned in the same breath as Oklahoma State’s Justin Blackmon, Baylor’s Kendall Wright, Notre Dame’s Michael Floyd, South Carolina’s Alshon Jeffery, Rutgers’ Mohamed Sanu and LSU’s Rueben Randle, as a potential first-round prospect.

But, as it stands, he may have to settle for being a draft steal.

During the interview, I asked Broyles a couple of times if he feels like a forgotten prospect in the draft mix right now. He didn’t like the sound of the word “forgotten” and vowed to be back and better than ever.

“Man, I hate how you say forgotten,” he said. “[Pause]… They can forget about me, but I’m going to be a stronger, faster, bigger, more prepared confident person when I get picked up by a team. The injury hasn’t changed my work ethic and it hasn’t changed who I am as a player. I’ll always play with a chip on my shoulder. People say that I’m too short, too small, too whatever. I’m going to go out there and make catches; lead by example. I’ll be ready to go for mini-camp; practice as hard as I can and hopefully fit in wherever I end up.”

 



Draft Nemesis: James vs. Miller
Posted: February 14, 2012
Comments
| Top


Lamar Miller is currently the third rated RB in my Top 100; just behind LaMichael James. How do the two RBs compare?
Miami Athletics

In my previous Draft Nemesis features I've analyzed the top-two quarterbacks in the draft, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Baylor's Robert Griffin III (click here to view it), as well as the top-two wide receivers, Oklahoma State's Justin Blackmon and Baylor's Kendall Wright (click here to view it) and offensive tackles, Iowa's Riley Reiff and USC's Matt Kalil (click here to view it).

Today, I turn my attention to the running back position. Since Alabama's Trent Richardson is in a class of his own, I decided to pose the No. 2 and 3 running backs, respectively, on my board in the latest Draft Nemesis feature: Oregon's LaMichael James and Miami's Lamar Miller.

Again, the Draft Nemesis feature is a condensed breakdown featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board, Mock Draft and/or Top 100.

Click here to view the latest Draft Nemesis feature between James and Miller.

 



Draft Nemesis: Reiff vs. Kalil
Posted: February 12, 2012
Comments
| Top


Riley Reiff isn't far behind Matt Kalil in ability, but Kalil currently has the edge over him.
Iowa Athletics

In my previous Draft Nemesis features I've analyzed the top-two quarterbacks in the draft, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Baylor's Robert Griffin III (click here to view it), as well as the top-two wide receivers, Oklahoma State's Justin Blackmon and Baylor's Kendall Wright (click here to view it). Three of those prospects are destined to be Top 10 picks with Wright being the one likely to be a Top 20 selection.

Today, I feature the top-two offensive tackles available in this year's draft, Iowa's Riley Reiff and USC's Matt Kalil. Again, the Draft Nemesis feature is a condensed breakdown featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board and Mock Draft.

Click here to view the latest Draft Nemesis feature between Reiff and Kalil.

 



Draft Nemesis: Luck vs. Griffin III
Posted: February 10, 2012
Comments
| Top


Andrew Luck is the clear favorite to be the top pick in the draft; Robert Griffin III could go No. 2 overall if a team trades up for him.
Stanford Athletics

In the first Draft Nemesis feature I analyzed Oklahoma State wide receiver Justin Blackmon against Baylor wide receiver Kendall Wright (click here to view it). At this point, Blackmon has the edge, but Wright is rising up draft boards and could ultimately land in the Top 10.

Today, I feature the top-two quarterbacks available in this year's draft, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Baylor's Robert Griffin III. Again, the Draft Nemesis feature is a condensed breakdown featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board and Mock Draft.

Over the next couple of months, I'll release scouting reports of top draft prospects. I've already released my report on Griffin III and it's linked in the Luck/Griffin III Draft Nemesis piece.

Click here to view the latest Draft Nemesis feature between Luck and Griffin III.

 



Draft Nemesis: Blackmon vs. Wright
Posted: February 8, 2012
Comments
| Top


Justin Blackmon is the No. 1 wide receiver on many draft boards, but is it possible Baylor's Kendall Wright surpasses him in the coming months?
OSU Marketing

As the NFL Scouting Combine approaches there are many positional battles that have to be sorted out. The debate between the top quarterbacks, Stanford's Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin, will take centerstage, and the top offensive tackles, defensive ends, linebackers, etc... will also be discussed.

Today, I breakdown the top two wide receivers, Oklahoma State's Justin Blackmon and Baylor's Kendall Wright, in a condensed manner, featuring a PowerGrid, attributes, top performances and current position in my Big Board and Mock Draft.

Over the next couple of months, I'll release scouting reports of top draft prospects and will be sure to have a complete report on Blackmon and Wright, along with other prospects that I pose in the Draft Nemesis feature.

Click here to check out the first Draft Nemesis feature between Blackmon and Wright.

 



Updated 1st Round Mock Draft
Posted: February 7, 2012
Comments
| Top


Riley Reiff will be a popular name throughout the draft process and could continue to climb in the Top 10.
Iowa Athletics

With the Senior Bowl behind us and a new NFL champion crowned (New York Giants), the status of the top senior prospects has changed and the first-round draft order is officially set.

In my previous mock draft, which was released on January 21st (click here to view it), I predicted a trade between the St. Louis Rams and the Washington Redskins. In this current mock draft, I predict the same trade with Baylor quarterback Robert Griffin III headed for the Redskins and Oklahoma State wide receiver Justin Blackmon going to the Rams.

There are some surprise selections in my latest mock draft and those picks may not be popular. A few players making their debut in my first-round are Marshall defensive end Vinny Curry, USC defensive end Nick Perry and Ohio State offensive tackle Mike Adams.

With that said, the Indianapolis Colts are on the clock... Click here to view my latest mock draft.

 



Updated Big Board & Top 100
Posted: February 5, 2012
Comments
| Top


Alshon Jeffery's stock continues to fall, but with a strong Combine performance he will reemerge.
South Carolina Athletics

With the Senior Bowl in the rearview mirror and the Scouting Combine just a few weeks away, I decided to update my Big Board and Top 100 to reflect the current status of this year’s top prospects.

Some changes were made to my Top 25; South Carolina defensive end Melvin Ingram and Georgia offensive lineman Cordy Glenn have elevated their draft status with their performance at the Senior Bowl. A couple of the players whose stock is on the decline are South Carolina wide receiver Alshon Jeffery and Notre Dame wide receiver Michael Floyd.

Click here to view my updated Big Board.

There were a number of prospects outside of my Top 25 that helped their draft stock in Mobile, Alabama, and their status can be seen in my Top 100; Marshall defensive end Vinny Curry, Connecticut defensive tackle Kendall Reyes, Utah State linebacker Bobby Wagner, Baylor center Philip Blake and Florida running back Chris Rainey were the highest gainers on my Top 100.

Click here to see who is rising and falling on my Top 100.

 



Vinny Curry Scouting Report
Posted: February 3, 2012
Comments
| Top


Vinny Curry has the ability to be the fourth player in Marshall's school history to be a first-round pick.
Marshall Athletics

This is the time of year where under-the-radar prospects can elevate their draft status with impressive showings at All-Star games, such as the Senior Bowl, and Scouting Combine with their performance during drills and team interviews.

One player who stood out at the Senior Bowl and now finds himself in the discussion as a potential first-round pick is Marshall defensive end Vinny Curry.

At 6-foot-3, 265 pounds, Curry, who recorded 26.5 sacks and 49.5 tackles for a loss during his four-year career, possesses the ideal blend of ability and intangibles to be the first defensive player selected in the first-round in school history.

If he continues his dominant display at the Scouting Combine and impresses talent evaluators during interviews, there's no question he will rise and flirt with the possibility of being a Day-One selection.

For a breakdown of Curry's strengths and weaknesses, click here for his scouting report.




All-Score 1st Round Defensive Team
Posted: February 1, 2012
Comments
| Top


Bryant Young had a Hall of Fame worthy career and is a member of the All-Score squad.
Courtesy of 49ers.com

Over a 20-year period, hundreds of players heard their names called in the first round of the NFL Draft. But of those hundreds of players only a small percentage actually lived up to their potential, and even a smaller percentage has gone on to be considered some of the games best.

The All Score 1st Round Defensive Team consists of 11 players – two defensive ends, two defensive tackles, a middle linebacker, two outside linebackers, two cornerbacks, a free safety and a strong safety – who were drafted in the first round between 1991 - 2011. There were a lot of tough decisions that were made when assembling this team, and that's to be expected when you're dealing with many all-time greats.

It’s likely that some of the selections will be challenged, but for the most part I believe the team will be universally accepted and recognized as a solid depiction of the best players at their respective positions.

Click here to view my All-Score 1st Round Defensive Team.



All-Score 1st Round Offensive Team
Posted: January 30, 2012
Comments
| Top


Willie Roaf is one of the best OTs in NFL history and a sure Hall of Fame inductee.
Louisiana Tech Athletics

Over a 20-year period, hundreds of players heard their names called in the first round of the NFL Draft. But of those hundreds of players only a small percentage actually lived up to their potential, and an even smaller percentage has gone on to be considered some of the games best.

The All Score 1st Round Offensive Team consists of 11 players - one quarterback, two running backs, two wide receivers, a tight end, two offensive tackles, two guards and a center – who were drafted in the first round between 1991 - 2011. There were a lot of tough decisions that were made when assembling this team, and that's to be expected when you're dealing with many all-time greats.

It’s likely that some of the selections will be challenged, but for the most part I believe the team will be universally accepted and recognized as a solid depiction of the best players at their respective positions.

Click here to view my All-Score 1st Round Offensive Team.



Top 20 NFL Draft Reflections
Posted: January 28, 2012
Comments
| Top


On the field, Michael Floyd is one of the best in the nation, but off the field he's had problems. Who does Floyd compare to?
Notre Dame Athletics

An extension of my Top 25 Big Board and an expanded version of my Top 10 Reflections; the Top 20 Reflections reflect the top 20 prospects listed on my Big Board, and features the players they mirror.

The Top 20 Reflections will be updated in conjunction with my Big Board. Some of the comparisons are obvious, but the goal isn't to identify every prospect with an All-Pro or Hall of Fame player - it's to be as realistic as possible about a players potential at the next level.

Note: Remember, the players that I compare each prospect to isn't a reflection of how their careers will unfold at the next level. I'm comparing them as prospects. For example, Robert Griffin III reflects Andre Ware as a prospect. How Griffin III develops at the next level will be determined by many factors, including the coaching, patience of the organization, situation, talent that surrounds him, etc... The same goes for every prospect.

With that said, click here to view my Top 20 Reflections.



Senior Bowl Practice Recap
Posted: January 27, 2012
Comments
| Top


The Senior Bowl is a part of the draft process and shouldn't dramatically impact a prospects rating.

The Senior Bowl is a great event and it serves a purpose; it's the kickoff to the draft process for the NFL. It's a place where NFL front offices, coaches and scouts get a chance to see "most of" the top senior talent up close for the first time.

But, let's keep the Senior Bowl in perspective, as Allen Iverson famously said, "I mean listen, we're sitting here talking about practice, not a game, not a game, not a game, but we're talking about practice."

That's all the Senior Bowl is, it's practice; an opportunity for NFL organizations and media members alike to observe the senior prospects up close, and to team representatives to acquire background checks and the media to conduct interviews for newspapers and websites.

In regards to this year's senior class, it's the weakest senior class that I've seen and without the top two senior wide receivers, Baylor's Kendall Wright and Notre Dame's Michael Floyd, in Mobile; the bottom line is there wasn't a first-round offensive skill player in attendance.

Oklahoma State quarterback Brandon Weeden had a good week. The 28-year old signal caller appeared confident, which wasn't a surprise since he's a former minor league baseball player and understands what it means to be a professional; stood tall in the pocket and kept his composure completing passes on the perimeter. But the overreaction to his performance was a bit over the top. While he delivered an accurate ball and did things well, his performance stood out because the quarterback competition he was up against was underwhelming.

Although, I believe Arizona quarterback Nick Foles was the most talented signal caller in Mobile. Even though he struggled at times, Foles has a chance to be a successful starter at the next level. He has a plus-arm and the poise to develop, but he must improve his awareness and especially his footwork. He's inconsistent in his drops and gets caught off balance, but once that's corrected, he will reward the team that invests a second-round selection in him.

One offensive player that intrigued me was Florida playmaker Chris Rainey. The NFL is all about speed and matchups, and with the right team and offensive coach, Rainey could be used in a similar role Darren Sproles has with the New Orleans Saints. If used correctly, Rainey will drive opposing defensive coordinators crazy with his explosiveness and playmaking in space. He's always a threat with the ball in his hands. Injuries have been a problem for Rainey in the past, but if he continues to impress this offseason he could elevate his stock into third-round consideration.


The draft process will determine who the better defender truly is, Courtney Upshaw or Melvin Ingram (photo above).
South Carolina Athletics

The defensive side of the ball was a different story. Alabama hybrid Courtney Upshaw was the most impressive prospect in Mobile. Despite his stature, he’s an instinctive football player, who is scheme diverse and is always around the ball. The other defenders who stood out to me were South Carolina hybrid Melvin Ingram, Marshall defensive end Vinny Curry, Connecticut defensive tackle Kendall Reyes, Louisiana-Lafayette cornerback Dwight Bentley and Utah State linebacker Bobby Wagner.

There were three more defenders that flashed during practice: North Carolina defensive end Quinton Coples and linebacker Zach Brown, as well as North Alabama cornerback Janoris Jenkins.

Coples had a good week and displayed the right attitude and work ethic NFL teams like to see, but where was that attitude and work ethic for the majority of the 2011 season? He received more attention this past season compared to what he saw in 2010, but a top-flight defensive end should be able to make adjustments and consistently produce.

Brown is a playmaker at the linebacker position, but his size and inexperience are factors to consider, and even though he was healthy during his first full season as a starter, durability, due to his size, will be a concern.

Overall, Jenkins played well during practice, but he had lapses in coverage. He displays moments of brilliance and the ability to lockdown most receivers, but he's guarded against speed and is a risk taker. He got beat badly by double moves at least three times, and Rainey just ran by him on a straight go-route down the near sideline.

As far as Saturday’s game, I expect it to be a defensive battle; that’s where the senior class talent resides in Mobile... on the defensive side of the ball.

Upshaw and Ingram should continue their strong week and fight for the right to be top 15 selections in April… I want to see Coples, Reyes, Curry and Jenkins have a solid showing in the game… I’m anxious to see how the Redskins coaching staff uses Rainey in the game, and if they line him up in multiple positions to exploit the North defense… I’m interested to see which of the six quarterbacks shines in the game. I’ll say Foles has the best showing.

Again, keep this week in perspective and don't allow a prospects flashes or failures - during practice in a new environment - weigh into your rankings too much.

"Hey it's strange to me too but we're talking about practice man, we're not even talking about the game, when it actually matters, we're talking about practice," Iverson said.



Top 10 NFL Draft Reflections
Posted: January 26, 2012
Comments
| Top


Andrew Luck is the best QB prospect since Peyton Manning, but does he reflect Manning?
Stanford Athletics

An extension of my Top 25 Big Board, the Top 10 Reflections reflect the top 10 prospects listed on my Big Board, and who those prospects compare to as past NFL prospects.

Moving forward, the Top 10 Reflections will be updated in conjunction with my Big Board. Some of the comparisons are obvious, but the goal isn't to identify every prospect with an All-Pro or Hall of Fame player - it's to be as realistic as possible about a players potential at the next level.

Note: Remember, the players that I compare each prospect to isn't a reflection of how their careers will unfold at the next level. I'm comparing them as prospects. For example, Robert Griffin III reflects Andre Ware as a prospect. How Griffin III develops at the next level will be determined by many factors, including the coaching, patience of the organization, situation, talent that surrounds him, etc... The same goes for every prospect.

With that said, click here to view my Top 10 Reflections.



Robert Griffin III Scouting Report
Posted: January 26, 2012
Comments
| Top


Robert Griffin III is an intriguing prospect with upside, but what are his strengths and weaknesses?
Baylor Athletics

The meteoric rise of Robert Griffin III, as one of the nation's premier quarterbacks in 2011, was an unexpected surprise that now has many fans and media wondering if he's worthy of the top pick in the 2012 NFL Draft.

The answer is no; he's not as NFL ready as Luck, and the transition to the NFL for Griffin III will take patience. However, he's destined to be a top three overall selection, and the team that selects Griffin III will likely have him behind center from Day One.

Tread slowly.

As great as Griffin III was this year and as incredible as his numbers were the past two years, he's far from being a polished product. The freestyle nature of his game is exciting and he has the potential to put incredible numbers on the board in his first few games at the next level. But once defenses get a chance to see his game on film and understand what his weaknesses are he will be exploited.

For a breakdown of Griffin III's strengths and weaknesses, click here for his scouting report.




blog comments powered by Disqus